Asking someone to be a godparent is its own small occasion, separate from the christening itself, and it deserves a gift that isn’t just a card with a question mark on it.
Get New Finds First
New arrivals and gift ideas, straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- How We Chose These Gifts
- Quick Comparison Table
- 1. Engraved Wooden Keepsake Box
- 2. Hand-Illustrated Card With a Personal Note
- 3. Freshwater Pearl Drop Earrings
- 4. Hammered Brass Stacking Ring
- 5. Kraft Cover Notebook, A5
- 6. Botanical Line Art Print, A4
- How to Choose the Right Gift for Your Godparent Ask
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The Bottom Line
Introduction
Working out how to ask someone to be a godparent is trickier than it sounds. Unlike a wedding proposal, there’s no centuries-old script for the moment or the gift that goes with it, so most people are improvising.
This guide rounds up six real gift ideas across different budgets, from a £4.50 card to a £24 pair of earrings, chosen specifically for the “will you be my godparent” moment rather than for the christening itself. Each one is a genuine product from our own catalogue, priced and described exactly as it’s sold, so what you see here is what you’d actually receive.
Here’s what we found after going through our full range with this one occasion in mind.
How We Chose These Gifts
We picked from CraftsGifted’s own catalogue using four criteria:
- Works even if the answer is a thoughtful “let me think about it”: nothing so final or so personalised that it would feel awkward if the person needed time to consider the request.
- Doubles as a keepsake: the recipient should want to hold onto it regardless of the outcome, not just unwrap it and move straight to the question.
- Spans a real budget range: from a small note-and-card gesture up to a proper jewellery gift, since not every relationship or every occasion calls for the same spend.
- Doesn’t presume the answer: we avoided anything permanently engraved with “Godmother” or “Godfather” before the person has actually agreed, since that puts unfair pressure on the response.
Quick Comparison Table
| Gift | Price | Category | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engraved Wooden Keepsake Box | £22.00 | Baby & Child | A proposal box filled with a note and small mementos |
| Hand-Illustrated Card | £4.50 | Cards & Stationery | A low-key, low-pressure way to ask |
| Freshwater Pearl Drop Earrings | £24.00 | Jewellery | A close friend or family member you’d already buy jewellery for |
| Hammered Brass Stacking Ring | £18.00 | Jewellery | Someone who wears understated, everyday pieces |
| Kraft Cover Notebook, A5 | £9.00 | Cards & Stationery | A godparent who’ll want to write letters to the child over time |
| Botanical Line Art Print, A4 | £16.00 | Art | Someone who’d rather hang the memory than wear or store it |
Prices shown are correct at the time of publication and set by our WooCommerce store; check the linked product page for current pricing before ordering.
1. Engraved Wooden Keepsake Box
The classic “proposal box” format, built around a real keepsake box rather than a throwaway prop.
This is the format most gift guides point to for a reason: a small box gives you somewhere to put the handwritten note asking the question, plus a couple of extras like a photo, a small trinket, or a printed scan sonogram if you’re asking before the birth. Our Engraved Wooden Keepsake Box is designed for exactly this kind of use: something a family keeps for years, not something built around one afternoon.
What we like:
- It’s a genuine keepsake box, not a novelty item made for a single occasion
- Room inside for a note plus two or three small extras
- Works whether you’re asking before or after the birth
What to be mindful of:
- Skip having it engraved with “Godmother” or “Godfather” before they’ve said yes; use a loose card or note for the actual question instead
- At £22.00 it’s a mid-range option, not the cheapest on this list
Best for: Parents who want the moment to feel considered, and who’d rather give something the person keeps than something they read once and put down. Not ideal if: You want something quick and low-cost for a wider group of potential godparents to choose from before you’ve settled on one person.
2. Hand-Illustrated Card With a Personal Note
Sometimes a well-written card does the job better than an elaborate gift box.
Not every ask needs a prop. Our Hand-Illustrated Card was designed for birthdays, but its blank interior and understated illustration style work just as well repurposed for a personal, handwritten “will you be my godparent” message. If you’re close enough to the person that the words matter more than the packaging, this is the option.
What we like:
- At £4.50, it’s the lowest-cost way to make the ask feel deliberate rather than casual
- Blank inside, so the message is entirely yours rather than a pre-printed script
- Easy to send if the person doesn’t live nearby
What to be mindful of:
- It doesn’t come pre-printed for this specific occasion, so the wording is on you
- If you want the moment to include a physical keepsake object, pair it with something small rather than sending the card alone
Best for: A close friend or sibling where a heartfelt, handwritten note will land better than a gift. Not ideal if: You’re asking someone more distant, where a tangible gift helps signal how much the request means to you.
3. Freshwater Pearl Drop Earrings
A proper jewellery gift for godparents you’d already be buying jewellery for on other occasions.
If the person you’re asking is close family or a lifelong friend, a jewellery gift can mark the moment the way a card can’t. Our Freshwater Pearl Drop Earrings sit at the higher end of this list at £24.00, and pearls in particular carry an association with new beginnings that fits the occasion without needing an inscription to explain it.
What we like:
- A gift with lasting everyday use, not something that only makes sense in the context of the ask
- Freshwater pearls read as a considered, occasion-appropriate choice without being overly formal
- Comes without engraving, so there’s no risk of committing to wording before you have an answer
What to be mindful of:
- Not everyone wears drop earrings; check the recipient’s usual style first
- At £24.00, it’s the most expensive option on this list
Best for: A close female friend or family member with pierced ears who you’d already consider giving jewellery to. Not ideal if: You’re not sure of their jewellery preferences, or you’re choosing between several possible godparents before deciding.
4. Hammered Brass Stacking Ring
A subtler jewellery option for someone who prefers understated, everyday pieces over statement jewellery.
Not everyone wants drop earrings, and not every budget stretches to £24.00. Our Hammered Brass Stacking Ring is £18.00 and reads as an everyday piece rather than an occasion-only one, which suits people who’d rather wear a gift regularly than save it for special occasions.
What we like:
- Everyday, wearable style rather than a piece that sits in a drawer
- Priced £6 lower than the earrings above, while still being a genuine jewellery gift
- Suits both men and women, depending on ring style preference
What to be mindful of:
- Ring sizing is worth checking before you buy; a ring that doesn’t fit undercuts the gesture
- Brass tones can vary slightly in how they read against different skin tones, so it’s worth checking a photo of the product before ordering
Best for: A godparent-to-be with an everyday, low-key style who’ll actually wear what you give them. Not ideal if: You don’t know their ring size and can’t ask without giving away the surprise.
5. Kraft Cover Notebook, A5
A practical gift for the godparent who’ll want to write to the child over the years, not just attend the christening.
Some godparents take the role as a chance to write letters to their godchild over time, whether that’s birthday notes, milestones, or advice to be read later. Our Kraft Cover Notebook, A5 at £9.00 gives that habit somewhere to start, and framing it as “somewhere to write to them as they grow up” turns a fairly ordinary notebook into a gift with a clear purpose.
What we like:
- Practical and useful on its own, not just decorative
- At £9.00, it’s an accessible mid-point between the card and the jewellery options
- Suits a godparent who’s more sentimental-in-practice than in gesture
What to be mindful of:
- It only works as a proposal gift if you explain the intended use; on its own, it just reads as a notebook
- Less immediately “special occasion” than jewellery or an engraved box, so it suits a specific kind of person rather than a general choice
Best for: A godparent you know will actually use it, someone who already writes cards, journals, or long messages rather than a quick text. Not ideal if: You want the gift itself to signal the occasion without extra explanation.
6. Botanical Line Art Print, A4
For a godparent who’d rather hang a memory on a wall than wear or store one.
Our Botanical Line Art Print, A4 is £16.00 and works well for someone whose home decor style you already know, or as a print to frame alongside the christening date once it’s confirmed. It’s a quieter option than jewellery, but it lasts on a wall in a way a card doesn’t.
What we like:
- A decorative gift the recipient can actually display, not just store away
- At £16.00, it sits comfortably in the middle of this list’s price range
- Suits people who prefer prints and home decor gifts over jewellery or stationery
What to be mindful of:
- It needs framing separately, which is an added cost and step for the recipient
- Style-dependent; check it suits their existing decor before choosing it over a more universal option
Best for: Someone whose home style leans toward botanical or line-art prints, who’ll want to hang rather than wear or write. Not ideal if: You’re not confident about their decor taste, or they’ve mentioned not having wall space for another print.
How to Choose the Right Gift for Your Godparent Ask
- How close are you already? If you’d already buy this person jewellery for their birthday, the pearl earrings or brass ring will feel consistent rather than sudden. If your relationship runs more on conversation and cards, the hand-illustrated card carries more weight than an expensive item would.
- What’s your budget for this specific moment? This list runs from £4.50 to £24.00 on purpose. There’s no evidence that a bigger spend makes for a more meaningful ask; a well-written note in a £4.50 card can land harder than an item chosen mainly because it cost more.
- Are you asking before or after the birth? According to the Church of England’s guide for parents, there’s no fixed rule on timing, so a keepsake box works either way, whether you’re filling it with a scan photo before the birth or a newborn photo after.
- Do you want the answer kept private until they’ve decided? Wedding and parenting etiquette guides, including You Said It’s advice on godparent proposals, generally recommend asking privately rather than over social media, so the person has room to think it over rather than feeling watched.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a godparent proposal gift?
It’s a small gift given at the moment you ask someone to be your child’s godparent, separate from any gift given at the christening itself. It can be as simple as a card or as involved as a filled keepsake box.
Do you have to give a gift when asking someone to be a godparent?
No. A heartfelt conversation or a handwritten card is enough on its own. A gift is a nice addition, not a requirement, and etiquette guides don’t treat it as obligatory.
When should you ask someone to be a godparent?
There’s no fixed timing. Some parents ask before the birth, others wait until after, and some wait until closer to the christening date itself. The Church of England’s guidance for parents doesn’t specify a required window.
What do you put in a godparent proposal box?
Common choices include a handwritten note asking the question, a small item like jewellery or a notebook, and sometimes a photo or scan picture. Keep it simple rather than overstuffed.
Should you ask godparents before or after the baby is born?
Either works. Asking beforehand gives the person time to think it over without the pressure of a newborn already in the room; asking afterwards lets you include a newborn photo in the gift.
What if someone says no to being a godparent?
It happens, and etiquette advice consistently recommends being prepared to accept a “no” gracefully, since the role is a genuine, ongoing commitment rather than an honorary title. Choosing a gift that isn’t permanently personalised (see our note on engraving above) makes this easier for everyone.
How many godparents does a child need?
This depends on the type of ceremony and the family’s own wishes. For an Anglican christening specifically, the Church of England recommends at least three godparents, though non-religious or other-denomination naming ceremonies don’t follow the same rule.
Do godparents have to be religious or baptised?
For a formal Anglican christening, yes: the Church of England’s guidance states that godparents must have been baptised themselves, since they take on a specific faith-related role in the ceremony. For a secular naming day, there’s no such requirement.
What’s a reasonable budget for a godparent proposal gift?
This list runs from £4.50 to £24.00, and any point in that range is defensible. The gift is a gesture marking the ask, not a measure of how seriously you’re asking.
Should you ask someone to be a godparent over social media?
Most etiquette guidance, including advice aimed at UK parents, suggests asking privately rather than publicly, so the person isn’t put under pressure to respond a certain way in front of an audience.
Can grandparents or siblings be godparents?
Yes, there’s no rule against it, and many families do choose close relatives. The main consideration is usually whether the relationship and commitment level fit the role, not the family tie itself.
What should you do if you can’t decide between two people?
It’s reasonable to ask more than one person, provided you’re comfortable exceeding whatever minimum number your ceremony requires. If budget is a factor across multiple people, the £4.50 card option makes it easier to ask several people without a large combined cost.
About This Research
CraftsGifted Editorial Team curates and writes CraftsGifted’s gift guides, working directly from the store’s own live product catalogue rather than generic third-party recommendations.
This article is based on a review of CraftsGifted’s full current catalogue against the specific occasion of asking someone to be a godparent, cross-checked against publicly available guidance from the Church of England and UK etiquette and card-industry sources cited above. Every price and product link reflects what is actually listed for sale at the time of writing.
Content reviewed and updated: 2026-09-25
The Bottom Line
If you want the classic, tactile version of this moment, the Engraved Wooden Keepsake Box at £22.00 gives you a real keepsake to build the ask around. If you’d rather keep it simple and let your words do the work, the £4.50 Hand-Illustrated Card is the low-pressure choice. For a close friend or family member you’d already buy jewellery for, either the pearl earrings or the brass stacking ring mark the occasion without needing an explanation.
Whichever you choose, keep it simple, ask privately, and give the person real room to say yes on their own terms.
Compare CraftsGifted’s Full Gift Range to check current pricing and availability before you order.
Related Articles
- 7 Christening and New Baby Gift Ideas: for the christening itself, once godparents are confirmed
- How to Pick a Thoughtful First Baby Gift: practical guidance for new-parent gifts more broadly
- How to Choose a Jewellery Gift: A Simple Guide: sizing and fit advice if you go with the earrings or ring
- 7 Engraved Keepsake Box Gift Ideas for Milestones: more keepsake box ideas for other life events
- How to Write a Thank-You Card Message People Remember: useful once your godparent has said yes
Enjoyed This? Stay in the Loop.
Join the newsletter for more gift guides like this one.
